Cork, Cloyne and Ross Diocesan Synod presidential address
PRESIDENTIAL ADDRESS
delivered by The Rt. Rev. Paul Colton, Bishop of Cork, Cloyne and Ross to The Synod of the Diocese on Saturday 12th June 2004 in the Skibereen, Co. Cork
Dear friends in Christ, we meet in his name, as the pilgrim people of God, to do the work of his Church in this Diocesan Synod of Cork, Cloyne and Ross – my sixth as Bishop!
This will be the last session of this Diocesan Synod in this triennium, and so I thank you for your voluntary commitment as Synod members throughout this period.
Remarkable Generosity – Thank you
As we begin our work today I wish to highlight the generosity of commitment of two members. Last month Canon JLB Deane completed 50 uninterrupted years as a member of Diocesan Council. Like Mr George Stoney he has completed it – not, we hope, as an endurance test – but as an act of self-offering and lay ministry in the Church. Likewise, The O’Donovan recently retired as Diocesan Treasurer and as a co-opted member of the Representative Church Body. We thank him for all his generous offering of time and ability for the work of Christ’s Church. At the end of this address it will be my pleasure to make a presentation to each of them, but I know you would wish to thank and salute them.
Deployment – Changes, Welcome and Farewell
Also as we begin our Synod, I congratulate those who, in the last year, have new appointments in the Diocese; those who are new among us in the ordained ministry, and I thank those to whom we have said farewell:
the Reverend Andrew McCroskery was appointed to Youghal Union
the Reverend Hazel Minion was ordained deacon
the Reverend Stella Mikhail and the Reverend Joy Ferguson were ordained priest
the Reverend Catherine Snyder Gibson has begun Ministry in Fermoy Union
the Reverend Bruce Hayes is the new incumbent here in Abbeystrewry
in August we look forward to welcoming the Reverend William Olhausen to Carrigrohane Union; and in October the Reverend Helene Tarneberg Steed will come from Sweden to the position of Dean’s Vicar at St Fin Barre’s Cathedral;
as anticipated at last year’s Synod we said farewell to the Very Rev. Trevor Lester who headed to Waterford as Dean
to the Reverend Sue Watterson who is in Dublin heading up the Church’s ministry of healing
and in February the Reverend Francis Rutledge left to go to the Diocese of Clogher
we thank them and say Good Bye – God bless.
R.I.P.
In sympathising with all who were bereaved since we last met year also we were saddened by the deaths of fellow pilgrims, and today I mention former members of this Synod:
Mrs Olive Walls who also served on Diocesan Council and was noted for selfless involvement in the Skiddys’ Charity.
Canon Jerram Burrows who served the bulk of his ministry in this Diocese as Headmaster of the Cork Grammar School.
The Venerable Brian Snow who was only here a short time, but served his first curacy in Christ Church.
Most recently the Reverend John Haworth, whose vocation was nurtured in the Christ Church context, served in many parts of the Church of Ireland; in this diocese in Kinneigh and in Fermoy and who, in retirement, volunteered his ministry generously and selflessly, travelling great distances, in order to sustain ministry where it would not otherwise have been sustained.
We offer our sincere sympathy to all their families, particularly to Rose Haworth in the midst of such recent bereavement.
The Familial Diocese
I make these personal remarks at the outset this year to emphasise and draw attention to our sense of ourselves as a familial diocese. We are like a family. That is what a diocese ought to be.
The Diocese
Broadly speaking a diocese is a territory under the spiritual leadership and oversight of a bishop and governed by a representative assembly – in our case, the Diocesan Synod, itself governed provincially by the General Synod. It is an established principle of both Anglican theology and Anglican Law that when we speak of the local Church we are referring not to the parish (as some have come to think), but rather the diocese.
As Anglicanism unfolds through its current controversies, we will, I believe, become increasingly conscious of this fundamental point. I believe before too long I will be reminding you that I have made this point; and the outworking of it will become ever more obvious and relevant.
Having said that, technical descriptions do little justice to the human reality of interdependence and mutual regard we experience here in Cork, Cloyne and Ross. This is a family. We should not take that for granted. Like all good relationships it is something that requires work. What do we build on?
our faithful pilgrimage in community with God the Holy Trinity, Father, Son and Holy Spirit
our opting in to the Church of Ireland as a framework for belonging and expression of that belief
mutual understanding
respect for diversity of opinion
loyalty
and openness
We also have to cultivate the maturity that enables us to know how to live with difference: difference in believing; in belonging; in lifestyle; in expression; in choices made and principles held. When someone says to me “This is a principle for me,” I say to them “Go gently; the person you say that to has principles as well.” In the area of belief this can be uncomfortable, but it is an inevitable part of the dialectic that goes with community life, especially within an inclusive faith community such as Anglicanism
In his book - Counting People In - Richard Thomas (Director of Communications for the Diocese of Oxford) sets parameters for what I am trying to articulate:
“So does it matter what you believe?” he asks. “Absolutely. The search for truth is at the heart of the gospel. And will anything do? No. Clearly the search for truth takes us on a pilgrimage of faith, where the search for an authentic experience of the divine mystery leads us to exclude false, misleading or just plain bad religious understanding and practice. Faith is not an irrational acceptance of the illogical or impossible. It is, at heart, a way,…of making sense of reality because reality, for the Christian is truth, and truth reveals God’s creative, forgiving energy and love. Thus the search for reality, for truth, for authenticity, is an important test of a genuine religious pilgrimage. Christians should not be afraid of the enquiring mind: we should celebrate it, even when the search takes us into uncomfortable territory….The ability to live with those who disagree with you has at least as much to do with your level of emotional maturity as it does your spiritual maturity; in fact the two may be closely linked.”
Census 2002
Counting People In was an opportune “read” for two reasons. First, the results of Census 2002: I tread carefully when it comes to statistics, mindful of Paul Brodeur’s counsel
“Statistics are human beings with the tears wiped off”
I believe we can make some fundamental statements about religion in Ireland on foot of Census 2002:
Religion - albeit in many guises - is still important to the people of Ireland.
Christianity, expressed in many ways, is still hugely significant.
The expression of Christianity is more diverse, more varied than we have ever known before in Ireland.
The number of people not espousing religion has increased hugely, to the point of being the second largest grouping in this section of the Census.
While that is significant it ought not to be overplayed, because at the same time all but one Christian denomination grew in numbers, some very significantly; the single largest percentage increase, albeit on a small starting number, being among Orthodox Christians.
So, for many churches such as ours, probably because of net migration, we are coming to terms with a surprise: increased numbers, in the Church of Ireland’s case by over one-fifth.
For us locally, we are told of an additional 5000 people we didn’t know about, so that presents local responsibilities. Which brings me to my second reason for valuing Richard Thomas’ book: Canon JLB Deane has painstakingly prepared a paper for us providing local analysis which has been circulated to you. What can we infer from it? He will give us some specific insights from his study. For my part I ask some general questions:
How are we to include and welcome these people? What changes do we need to make within our churches and as and between the now established ecumenical relationships between our churches to draw them in? What are our relationships with new groups of Christians and new churches in Ireland?
I have a very graphic illustration of this recently when representatives of the sizeable Orthodox community now living in Cork came to The Palace on a courtesy call. Sadly within two weeks I was worshipping with them at the funeral of a young Russian student at Ashton School who had died in a car crash.
Most important, arising from the census: who are these people and where are they?
Why are there such gaps between the Census 2002 figures and the parochial census figures?
Let me suggest a reason – it’s something I have been harping on about for years: we take a too narrow view of who belongs. In spite of our clichés about evangelism; and our assertion that we are inclusive; and our syntax about outreach we still have what Richard Thomas calls a “participant” model of membership.
Participants are those who belong by participating in the organized life of a church. We recognise them readily because we see them; they sign up; they pay in; they help out. “The there are those who may not come, even irregularly, to worship. They will not be found on lists…But if asked, they will state quite firmly that they belong.” These are associates.
‘Participating’ Christians are far outnumbered by ‘associates’; those seldom if ever attending church, but claiming allegiance – who belong by believing. Thomas looks at ways the church can advance their pilgrimage, helping them understand the faith they hold, and guiding their spirituality. The medieval parish system isn’t tuned, he points out, to the modern culture of mobility, independence, literacy and communication technology.
A key question for us has to be how are we to minister to such people? How does the church communicate with those who have a belief in God but who do not find the Church an essential part of that belief?
When we articulate this theology of belonging we need to work it out not only in terms of narrowly defined membership of the Church, but against the yardstick of the incarnation which draws us beyond the church into the community in which the Church is set, embracing the most fundamental of all Christian doctrines, that of creation itself.
Confusing Times
These perspectives challenge us greatly and may even make us hugely uncomfortable. Living through a cusp era, such as this one, rapidly changing,
Last month the results of Behaviour and Attitudes Marketing Research were presented under the heading “High Anxiety: Keeping up with the Jones in Modern Ireland.” Some of the outcomes were hugely interesting and I am grateful Hugh St Leger, Marketing Manager of Statoil Ireland (a son of this diocese) for this information:
The general thesis of the paper is that, while Irish people are increasingly better off they are not necessarily happier or more content and also.
That they are finding new things to believe in.
Car ownership graph Telephone ownership graph
Home entertainment equipment graph
Church Attendance figures:
Church attendance figures graph
Weekly attendance at church service.mass graph
Cinfidence in institutions graph
A key conclusion was that we as people are seeking new things to believe in.
Moving forward
In this sort of scenario we are coming to terms with the sort of Christianity exemplified in the European Values Studies undertaken as recently as 2000 and articulated in the catch phrase coined by Grace Davie sociologist of religion: “believing without belonging.”
There is a measure of uncomfortable (ideological) chaos and fear, pessimism even, about the times in which we live. This presents dangers and attractive traps that some, I believe are falling into. At this juncture they will do nothing, in the longer term view, for our mission and calling. I speak of
a new and vigorous fundamentalism: a retreat to a literalism that not only tries to fly in the face of rationalism; but also castrates the sense of mystery that is such an inescapable part of existence, by peddling a cheap certainty;
Also, I speak of a neo-McCarthyism which instead of being a red scare, tries to disarm diversity of opinion and practice in favour of standardisation. It’s a type of neo-totalitarianism that tends towards crossing the boundary between the public and the private in people’s lives; interfering in private concerns in order, supposedly to attain a perfection ecclesial society.
This is an old Fourth Century heresy in a new guise: donatism – the suggestion that only those living a blameless life may belong in the church; and, therefore, in the case of clergy, that the validity of any sacrament depends upon the personal worthiness of the priest administering it.
These insidious trends in some sections of the Church will do nothing to meet the evangelistic challenges of our time.
What sort of Church?
That being the case what sort of Church do we need? I’ve already said that we need to move beyond our participant model of membership. For more insight I turn paradoxically to the world of the secular detective novel – those of Alexander McCall Smith – currently on the top sellers’ lists in the bookshops in great numbers of titles. In the opening pages of his first - The No.1 Ladies’ Detective Agency we read of the lady detective Mma Ramotswe:
“She was a good detective, and a good woman. A good woman in a good country, one might say. She loved her county….I love all the people whom God made, but I especially know how to love the people who live in this place. They are my people, my brothers and sisters. It is my duty to help them to solve the mysteries in their lives. That is what I am called to do….”
The impulses of incarnational ministry are here: being; being in a particular place; knowing that place; loving that place; loving the people of that place; viewing them as brothers and sisters; the sense of duty and calling – and above all the living with mystery: journeying together in pursuit of truth within mystery.
The Best-Run Launderette
The London-based priest, writer and broadcaster Eric James, in a sermon told of his late friend - Clem Mitford - who owned a chain of launderettes and who said to him one day “You know, whatever else we do at this Church, we must run it like the best-run launderette. The world must know where it is, what it’s for, and when it’s open.”
Parishes of this diocese could do a lot worse as part of their strategising than scrutinise themselves under these headings
Where it is: Can people find you? Do you try to get them to find you? Do you assume everyone knows the way? (If I as bishops can’t find you what hope is there for total strangers?)
What it’s for? Have we a sense of priorities. Worked out prayerfully, thoughtfully and purposefully? Have we a sense of what we are doing and to what end?
When it’s open: are those notice boards up to date? Are our service schedules intelligible, instinctive and predictable? I believe we are not served well by schedules which look like matrices on a Leaving certificate maths paper offering permutations, variations and unpredictable sequences. We arrange to watch certain television programmes for example because we always know what time they are at and on what channel.
Last year - looking ahead – six things:
Last year, towards the conclusion of my address I said “The year ahead will be busy. Certainly I can see six major things on the agenda”
Safeguarding Trust
The Hard Gospel
European Capital of Culture, 2005
The new Book of Common Prayer
Human Sexuality.
reflection on ministry
And indeed that was the case.
Safeguarding Trust
In the case of Safeguarding Trust, its re-introduction in the Diocese will be completed next week with the issuing to Select Vestries of training certificates in respect of youth workers and panel members. Prior to that, starting last summer,
the legal basis of the Code of Good practice was clarified;
a training team was recruited and trained: Christine Hilliard, Tom Cremin and Hilda Beamish; we are grateful to them and especially to Ann Hevers who took Hilda’s place when the need arose;
most of the clergy have now had revision training;
new panel members were trained;
215 youth workers in the Diocese, nominated by the parishes, were trained. Four training sessions were held last month.
What is most important in this area is that the policy and good practice articulated on paper are lifted out of the text and implemented in the life of the parishes and diocese.
The Hard Gospel
Last November a special regional synod was held to respond to the report on sectarianism – The Hard Gospel. This process continues in the Church of Ireland. It has not been completed, and there is plenty of scope for the agenda the group have set. For my part my concern, based on my overview of the Diocese continues to be that we tend to see this as an issue only appropriate to other people in other places. As I said on the day, at its nub it is about how we handle the free expression of difference; how, as the sub-title of the report challenges, we deal positively with that difference. The challenging question for each of us is - do I see in others around me, especially those different from me, a reflection of God’s glory? – A question which integrates, I believe, both with the current debates in our church and with that neo-quasi-totalitarianism to which I have already referred.
The Book of Common Prayer
Throughout the last nine months we have been gearing up for the arrival in our pews last Sunday of the new Book of Common Prayer.
Central Liturgical Officer (Canon R Rountree)
Diocesan Liturgical Officer (Dean M Burrows)
Diocesan Programme of Preparation
Pastoral Letter and Posters
Diocesan Magazine Articles and Website
Diocesan Prayer
Diocesan Council briefing
Ordering the books!
Taster/Introductory liturgies
Training for clergy and Diocesan Readers
Rural Deanery Visits
Our next phase will be our Training for Difference phase
The Psalter
Holy Baptism
Enriching the contemporary language Eucharist
Rediscovering the traditional language Eucharist
Service of the Word
Again it’s about lifting words out of books and making them live: live in the worship and spirituality of our lives as Christians and in our churches.
European Capital of Culture, 2005
I myself and clergy of the city parishes have been having conversations in relation to the European Capital of Culture with the organisers concerned. Much more remains to be done in this sphere by us and together with our ecumenical partners in relation to this endeavour. Just as the Churches of Manchester were involved in the Commonwealth Games; and those of Athens are preparing for the Olympics this summer, the churches of Cork, should I believe engage with this opportunity in 2005.
Human Sexuality
In the past year, as anticipated, the debate about human sexuality catapulted Anglicanism onto the media agenda worldwide. As I indicated would happen, the Bishops did issue their Pastoral Letter on Human Sexuality last year; and currently have initiated a process of consultation and receiving of submissions from interested parties. For my part, in a widely publicised sermon on Christmas Day 2003 I have already indicated my personal views on this subject.
On the international front, the Archbishop of Canterbury established the Lambeth Commission which is being chaired by our own Archbishop of Armagh, not to examine the issue of human sexuality per se, but to study the nature of our communion as an Anglican family and how that works. We will be hearing much more about this in the year to come when, as the debate continues, very challenging times will be testing. It is to be deplored that in Anglican churches all over the world, some are at work sowing the seeds of the idea of institutionalising split and division in church structures.
Reflection on Ministry
Our Diocesan Day of Reflection on Ministry last September, facilitated by the Reverend Chris Webb, Renewal Officer of the Council for Mission and Ministry in the Church in Wales, proved stimulating and dovetailed with a similar process of reflection nationally. The Ministry Advisory Group in the Diocese and the Diocesan Council both received Chris Webb’s reflections, and considerable thought has been given, though it has to be said, without agreement because of financial constraints, to how we communicate most effectively to the participants and more widely the outcomes of the day.
People often ask what such occasions achieve. In this instance
it served as an encouragement that many of the small steps we are already taking are significant ones in the right direction
it underscored the emphasis on lay ministry and
as the Diocese moved forward in its work, I believe, it has channelled us forward in three new enterprises:
the post of Diocesan Education Officer – currently advertised;
the moving forward with the Bishop’s Course in Pastoral Work for which start-up funding has been received from the Priorities’ Fund; and
a review, currently under way, of the potential for a part-time youth worker in the Diocese.
Even if these were the only tangible outcomes they would be worthwhile in themselves.
Last year I referred at length to the large numbers of people and their wide range of involvement in lay ministries of all sorts in the Diocese. The day of reflection on ministry set me thinking from my overview position as to what we have been doing and have done more recently in the field of ministry. Looking at them under a number of headings I realise that for a small part of the Church we are often too hard on ourselves about what we are achieving with very limited resources. An incomplete list identified from my perspective of overview which I outline for you in order to encourage you includes:
Faith Development
the Bishop’s Course in Theology (a second group are about to graduate)
Millennium revision of Diocesan Cycle of Prayer
Millennium Prayer and BCP 2004 Prayer
Daily Prayer cards
Two Lent courses
Post of Diocesan Education Officer advertised
Provision of seasonal liturgies for use in the parishes
Inter-faith day and consultation
The Wreath of Life – spirituality in Sweden
Children’s and Youth Ministry
Review of Youth Work
Reordering of arrangements for Confirmation
Y Bother event for the newly confirmed
Millennium visit of Roly the Clown
New Diocesan Youth Council
Introduction of Follow Me in the primary schools
Reintroduction of Safeguarding Trust
Training seminars for teachers and school Boards of Management
Appointment of whole-time Chaplain at UCC
Almost three hundred people involved in youth work
Our on-going commitment to and involvement in ICICYMA - Garryduff
Communication and Outreach
New framework for part-time DCO set up
Raising the Church’s profile in the local media
Reworking of the Coat of Arms for modern usage
Diocesan website set up and webmaster appointed
Information leaflet newly formatted
Diocesan Development
Episcopal Visitation 2001 – where are we as a Diocese?
Parish study questions relating to the Episcopal Visitation
Review of Diocesan Synod
Study under way concerning relocation of Diocesan Office
Pastoral Ministry
New Diocesan Healing and Pastoral Care Committee about to begin its work
Lay visitors
Mini CPE
Hospital Chaplains’ Training
In-Service training for clergy
Training scheme for lay ministers of the Eucharist
The Elderly
Saint Luke’s Home
Lapps’ Court and Lapps’ Charity
Kingston College
Support for the Ministry
Diocesan Information and Resource Pack
Policy development
Parish Readers
Lay assistants at the Eucharist
Holy Communion by Extension
Funding for Continuing Ministerial Education
Clergy Conferences:
Preaching
Rural Ministry
Liturgy
Ministry Today
Training Days
Tax
Suicide and Para-suicide
Liturgy
Interfaith dialogue
Marriage counselling
Children and Communion
Funding of attending training events e.g. Céiliúradh; Hospital Chaplains’ Courses
Computer training courses – introductory and advanced – for clergy and lay people
Review of policy on Sabbatical Leave for Clergy
Introduction of formalised provision for Clergy Retreat and Study week
Provision of the Constitution of the Church of Ireland to all clergy
Provision of reading and study material for clergy and lay readers
Specific information resources prepared on
Marriage Law
Copyright
Data Protection
Advisory guidelines from Diocesan Council to Select Vestries concerning administrative backup for clergy
Diocesan Policy on CME and on Ministerial Review
On-going Challenges
Even with a long list like this the sense of what more remains to be done is overwhelming. Let us work collaboratively step by step with patience and steadfastness, supporting one another and building one another up as the people of God.
Thank you
As always I could not approach the end of my address without highlighting my immense gratitude to so many people who serve the diocese in so many ways: to all who in ordained ministry take on additional roles – my three Domestic Chaplains; my Examining Chaplain; the Rural Deans, the Diocesan Director of Ordinands, the Warden of Readers the Reverend Robert Kingston who has now stepped down from that position; to the Archdeacon; our Diocesan Communications Officer; our Diocesan Webmaster Brendan Kearns; our Diocesan Architect, Bill Brady; our Diocesan Registrar, John Jermyn, his secretary Jean Wade and the so-many colleagues in that law firm who advise me generously on hosts of occasions ; and my own secretary, Ruth Wolfe; to Ruby Veitch, assistant secretary at the Diocesan Office and our Diocesan Secretary, Wilfred Baker. Thank you to each and every one of you for all that you do not least all of our volunteers.
Now let us turn to the business of our Synod for the good of Christ and part of his Church here in Cork, Cloyne and Ross.
+Paul Cork:
12 th June, 2004
For further information please contact:
Church of Ireland Press Office Church of Ireland House 61–67 Donegall Street Belfast, BT1 2QH
Some cookies are necessary for us to manage how our website behaves while other optional, or non-necessary, cookies help us to analyse website usage. You can Accept All or Reject All optional cookies or control individual cookie types below.
These cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may disable these by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.
Analytics cookies
Analytical cookies help us to improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage.